deviant art

Deviant Login Shop
 Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
more ▶

Featured in Groups:

Details

April 9, 2010
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 9
Favourites: 0
Views: 205 (0 today)
[x]

Help please?

Journal Entry: Fri Apr 9, 2010, 3:23 AM
Facebook l Gallery l dA Portfolio l Watch Me l Note Me


I am trying to figure out what technique to use for my Gawain comic (you can find fragments of the storyboard in my gallery). It would be nice to have colour, but I'm not good enough at watercolour or digital colouring to be able to undertake colouring an entire comic that way. Now I'm thinking that maybe I could pencil the comic (no inks) and colour it with colour pencils. I have posted a small experiment and would very much appreciate your opinion.



Do you think it would be nice to have a completely pencilled comic? How about colour versus greyscale? Or do you think inking is preferable? How do you think pencilled art will reproduce/print?

Opinions and advice are very, very welcome. Please do let me know what you think!



CSS made by `TwiggyTeeluck
Texture by `Princess-of-Shadows
  • Mood: Uneasy
Add a Comment:
 
:iconcabepfir:
*cabepfir Apr 12, 2010  Professional Traditional Artist
What about: 1) Sepia inks (in a Will Eisner way); 2) monochromatic colouring, in your case with red? (example by Igort: [link])
Reply
:iconsigune:
*Sigune Apr 12, 2010  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Hm. Never really thought about sepia... Though I have been drawing the Prologue in brown and red, now that you mention it :).

Monchromatic colouring: I'm thinking about it. Red won't suffice, though - the Green Knight is going to show up at some point ;)...
Reply
:iconjoeyv7:
My immediate reaction to your question was a preference for inked comics. But when I see your examples, I think you could use what you may *think* is an inadequacy, to your advantage. I think a comic done like the middle image would be more unique and atmospheric compared to inked/hard lines; choosing to color important areas only could add even more emphasis on what you're trying to say :hmm: The last two images are gorgeous, but the middle one is just as striking in my opinion, and wouldn't mean as much work for you :painter:
Reply
:iconsigune:
*Sigune Apr 9, 2010  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
You know, the reason why I am asking around so much is because I'm not convinced that inks are the way for this comic. For my Snape fancomic, they were a natural choice. I didn't really have to think about it - inks, lots of black and cross-hatching were just right. But then, ink is so Snape! With Gawain it's different: his colour is red. His element is fire and he is connected to the sun.

I'm worried that b/w - especially stark black inks - will make the atmosphere too dark. Though - well, Linda Medley's Castle Waiting is entirely in inks and isn't gloomy at all :)...

The pencilled and coloured style does give me a pleasant, tingly feeling for this story. I think I'll try a complete page and see what that looks and feels like (and how long it takes me *g*).

Thanks very much for your input! :smooch:
Reply
:iconjoeyv7:
Most welcome! Looking forward to seeing it :pc:
Reply
:iconjoeyv7:
. . . and if you find pencil is too soft, couldn't you tweak it (adding saturation/contrast, etc.) after you scan or photograph the image . . . or at some point when you make it a digital image like here (sorry, don't know how to say it :slow: )
Reply
:iconsigune:
*Sigune Apr 9, 2010  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I get the impression that since digital colouring has become popular, quite a few artists are not inking their pencils anymore. They enhance the contrast, as you say, and the digital colour goes over (or under) that. Johane Matte's fancomic Water Tribe is basically pencils + digitally added shadows - and personally, I don't think a comic needs much more than that.
Reply
:icondonguri7:
I like the idea of a penciled comic - how it would reproduce, I have no clue. The one on the right is my favorite, but that's a lot of work. What about a partially colored comic? Peoples face, important bits of the scene are colored, but the rest fades away into pencil sketchiness. Just a thought.

:heart:
Reply
:iconsigune:
*Sigune Apr 9, 2010  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
The one on the right is not much more work than the middle one; it's just a matter of adding texture in Photoshop. I do like your idea of letting less important elements fade - but I think it will work better with a texture than on a white page.

Thanks a lot for your suggestion! :)
Reply
Add a Comment: